Protein shakes are intended to enhance protein intake in a regular diet, which makes them better suited for snacking or weight gain. 

But can a protein shake replace a meal? A simple answer is no. There is not enough fiber in a protein shake, so an hour or two later you can feel hungry. 

Let’s examine the differences between a protein shake and a meal replacement and discuss how to choose the best one for you.

Can a Protein Shake Replace a Meal What Do Experts Say

Protein Shakes vs Meal Replacement Shakes

A common choice for athletes and fitness enthusiasts looking to increase their protein intake is protein drinks, which are designed to help build muscle. They have fewer additional vitamins and minerals and a larger protein content (around 25 grams per serving) than carbohydrates. 

You can make protein drinks more healthy by making sure they have all the necessary components. So, can a protein shake replace a meal? 

Snacking is the ideal way to enjoy them. Because protein shakes don’t contain all the nutrients that regular meals do. You should not use to replace a meal.

For those on a tight schedule or trying to lose weight, meal replacement shakes provide a quick and easy meal replacement option. 

They can assist in meeting daily nutritional demands by offering 200–400 calories along with vital nutrients like fibre, carbs, vitamins, minerals, and protein. 

Shakes help you lose weight by lowering your calorie consumption and, because of their high protein content, keeping you fuller for longer than unhealthy snacks or breakfast. 

Shakes are a better option than fast food as they don’t contain added sugar or artificial additives.

Can a Protein Shake Replace a Meal?

Protein shakes only contain sugar and a small number of vitamins and minerals that are necessary for a balanced diet. So when you are thinking can a protein shake replace a meal or not, the direct answer is no. 

You can not use them as a substitute for meals because of their restricted nutritional profile. 

Meals are enhanced by them, not replaced. Meal replacement shakes, on the other hand, can serve as meal replacements because they are designed to offer a complete combination of nutrients that are required for survival.  

Nutritionists advise replacing breakfast with protein shakes exclusively. but only once or twice. You can’t use it for a meal replacement forever. 

Because even premium products cannot provide your body with a steady supply of the right ratio of carbohydrates, fibre, and other nutrients that it requires.

You could use different dietary supplements to counteract the imbalance of vitamins and other nutrients. You could also make it easier on your body and add some diversity to your diet by choosing the correct foods.  

Athletes, who are trying to gain muscle or reduce weight, rely on using protein powder shakes in very specific ways.

What Should I Look for in a Shake for Meal Replacement?

The nutritional content and composition of meal replacement shakes might differ significantly. It’s crucial to check the nutritional labels to make sure the food counts as a meal substitute rather than just a snack.

A decent meal replacement shake ought to have a minimum of:

  • 170 calories
  • 25% of the recommended daily intake of vitamins and minerals
  • 3 gm of fibers 
  • 17 grams of protein

What Should You Eat as a Meal Replacement Protein Shake?

Amino acids make up protein. A “complete” protein shake contains all nine of the amino acids your body is unable to create on its own. Look for one that meets this requirement.

Protein powders that can be combined to create protein shakes that serve as meal replacements typically include one or more of the following:

  • Whey-based protein
  • Protein casein
  • Protein from egg whites
  • Protein from soy
  • Pea-based protein
  • Protein from rice

A range of proteins is included in certain formulae, especially plant-based protein powders, to provide the optimal mix of amino acids.

How to use protein powder as a meal replacement?

Select your basis for carbohydrates. Since the emphasis of most protein shakes is on protein, they tend to be low in carbohydrates. However, if you are replacing a meal, You need carbohydrates to keep us going. 

  • Oats, bananas, and your preferred milk can all contribute to the amount of carbohydrates in your smoothie.
  • Include some protein. We suggest trying our vegan protein, PERFORM, which has 25 grams of plant-based protein, 6 grams of BCAA, and a variety of superfoods like lucuma, acai berries, and reishi mushrooms. 
  • Select your vegetables and fruits. Since many of us already don’t get sufficient greens in our diets, adding kale, spinach, and other colorful vegetables to a meal replacement drink is a terrific way to make sure you’ve got your recommended daily intake of veggies.
  • Select a fat. For added protein and fibre, add some nut butter, avocado, or your fave seed!
  • You may customize, enhance taste, and add nutrition to your shake by adding extras. While we wouldn’t advise flooding your shake-like creation with sugar or artificial sweeteners, we wouldn’t object to a little cacao powder or sweet berry sprinkled on top.

The Advantages of Protein Shakes for Losing Weight

Let’s have a look at the advantages of protein shakes on weight loss.

  • They might lower calorie intake and improve satiety

Protein shakes can help lower overall calorie consumption and prevent cravings because of their satiating nature. Can a protein shake replace a meal? You can cut back on calories and hunger by having a protein shake as a snack or as a meal replacement. 

Those who have trouble controlling their portions or who snack frequently may find this to be of particular use. 

  • They may aid in maintaining muscle mass

Since complete amino acid profiles are frequently included in protein shake formulations, they can aid in promoting muscle protein synthesis. It is necessary to maintain lean muscle mass and a healthy metabolism. 

An extra source of protein that can assist in maintaining lean muscle mass is protein shakes. Your metabolism benefits from maintaining muscle mass since it increases calorie burning even while you’re at rest, according to Best.

  • They are easy to use and swift

Protein shakes are undoubtedly convenient for people who are often on the go or have trouble making or eating traditional meals.

Various Timing Options

You can pick when to consume the protein shake in place of a whole-food meal when following a once-daily shake diet. A protein shake is a great choice for breakfast because it’s easy to prepare and doesn’t need much effort in the morning.

There are other options for breakfast besides protein shakes. If you like to eat at your desk or have a lot of meetings, schedule one for lunch. You might also think about having your shake in place of dinner. After working out, a protein smoothie for dinner can be especially beneficial.

According to a September 2018 review published in Frontiers in Nutrition, there is strong evidence that eating protein before and after a workout can improve your body’s capacity to grow muscle and recover from strenuous activity. 

After working out, having a protein shake instead of dinner could be a wise move to improve your recuperation and performance.

Can a Protein Shake Replace a Meal: FAQs?

Can I have a protein shake and skip dinner?

Protein smoothies can help you reduce your daily calorie intake, which can aid in weight loss, in place of meals. However, you’ll eventually have to resume consuming solid food. 

How many protein shakes may one have in place of a meal?

Protein smoothies should only be consumed once or twice a day, and for brief periods.

Is two protein scoops excessive?

You should only consume two scoops (one serving) of protein powder each day.

Which protein smoothie is ideal for losing weight?

Whey protein powder with 100% Premier Protein.
Whey protein powder from NOW Sports.
Vanilla Ascent Native Whey.
Owyn Powdered Plant-Based Protein.
Vega Sport Protein.
KLEAN Isolate.

What are protein powder’s downsides?

If you have specific allergies or intolerances, they might be dangerous for you. 
They could result in stomach problems. 
Nutrient imbalances may result from them.


Categorized in:


Last Update: June 25, 2024